Breadcrumb

Morocco

The role of CSR

Only a few local companies are socially engaged in Morocco, a country that is in the middle range in terms of its development (HDI ranking: 130th). The public generally pays little attention to CSR.
Foreign investors, on the other hand, are serving as role models with respect to social engagement and helping to raise awareness of this topic. French companies are particularly numerous in the Moroccan market. Among the German companies that have been active in Morocco for many years are Siemens, Bayer, BASF, Beiersdorf, Lufthansa and TUI.

Morocco offers a variety of opportunities for CSR projects. So far, vocational training has been a particular focus. German companies recognize that they need to provide basic and further training for their employees, since the Moroccan system is not producing enough skilled workers. German companies might also take advantage of their experience in such areas as environmental technology, water treatment and renewable sources of energy.

Politicians are urging the adoption of European environmental standards and regulations, since this is essential if Moroccan exports – especially textiles, shoes and food – are to remain competitive. The European Union’s Neighborhood Policy and preparations for the free-trade zone to be launched in 2012 are having a significant effect on Moroccan industry. Businesses in Morocco are striving for responsible and sustainable corporate management, not least because of the influence of the European market.
International organizations, too, are raising awareness of CSR: The MENA Responsible Business Forum is an initiative of the MENA-OECD Investment Program; its objective is to assist the governments of the regions in creating the necessary conditions for investments in sustainability and social development. This program is funded by InWent, the UN Development Program, the World Bank and the Bertelsmann Stiftung, among others.

Intermediaries such as GTZ are involved in public-private partnerships to help companies meet international standards (“mise à niveau”). For example, GTZ conducted a market study for the Argand’Or company, which partners with women’s cooperatives to produce hand-pressed argan oil using traditional methods.

CSR understanding

In Morocco, as in every Islamic society, wealthy families and companies are expected to be involved in charitable projects. Against this background, CSR is viewed primarily in terms of philanthropy. This generally applies only to Muslim companies.

On the occasion of a national conference on investment (Intégrales de l'Investissement) in 2005, King Mohammed VI underscored the country’s commitment to a socially responsible and environmentally friendly economic and growth policy. Since then, measures to achieve that goal have been introduced: For example, the General Confederation of Moroccan Enterprises (CGEM) has a program to recognize companies that live up to their social responsibilities and the principles of sustainable economic activity (CGEM Label). The Moroccan Association of Textile and Apparel Industries, too, awards a label to worthy companies (fibre citoyenne).

Expectations towards companies

The Moroccan government expects German companies to assume social responsibility, an expectation that is often expressed only indirectly. The government holds competitions and awards prizes for outstanding CSR projects.

German companies have a good reputation in the area of vocational training. Since Morocco suffers from a lack of skilled workers, many companies need to provide the necessary training. In this context German companies can share their experience with the dual training system in their home country. Morocco also has a high rate of illiteracy – roughly 48 percent. The government has passed an educational reform bill, but German companies are still well advised to invest in training for their employees or other young people.

It should also be noted that German consumers expect companies to show responsibility throughout their value chains. International codes of conduct such as the BSCI Code (Business Social Compliance Initiative), which also covers the textile industry,  are an important factor encouraging German companies to behave responsibly.

Basic conditions

Government regulations – Implementation of international regulations

ILO
Morocco has ratified seven of the ILO’s core labor standards. The only one that has not yet been ratified is No. 87, “Freedom of Association and Protection of the Right to Organize,” from 1948.

Practical implementation

Abolition of forced labor
No concrete information is available about forced labor in Morocco. It must be assumed, however, that immigrants from other African countries who have no way of earning a living are involved in such illegal activities as prostitution and forced labor in connection with human trafficking rings.

Freedom of association and right to collective bargaining
Nearly all employed persons in Morocco have the right to form or join unions without prior permission; however, this involves cumbersome administrative hurdles. Members of the judiciary as well as homeworkers and farmhands are not governed by labor law, and are therefore not permitted to form unions. Individual organizations have the right to select their representatives freely, but this right is limited by the requirement that union officials must have Moroccan citizenship. In addition to the national federation of trade unions, Union Marocaine du Travail (UMT), there are two other union associations. Labor law prohibits firing employees for involvement in legitimate union activities, and the courts have the authority to order the rehiring of employees who have been arbitrarily let go. They can also require the respective employer to pay compensation as well as outstanding wages and salaries.

The right to collective bargaining is affirmed by Morocco’s labor law, but only the “most representative” trade union, which represents at least 35 percent of all employee delegates elected at the company level, is authorized to participate in collective bargaining. The law does not expressly stipulate whether collective bargaining is permitted for certain categories of public servants (teachers, prison workers, etc.).

The right to strike is guaranteed by the constitution (Art. 14), but it is subject to certain restrictions. For example, arbitration is required by law. According to statutory provisions, the decision to strike can be taken by the trade union or – if most employees are not part of the union – by a two-thirds majority of the company’s employees. The employer must be informed of the impending strike seven days in advance. Strikes are prohibited in sectors that involve vital services. Civil servants may be punished for going on strike.

Elimination of child labor
Approximately 30 percent of the population is under the age of 15. According to the US Department of Labor, 13.5 percent of boys and 12.8 percent of girls between the ages of 7 and 14 are working. Agriculture accounts for most of their employment (60 percent), followed by industry and service jobs.

Paid child labor is illegal in Morocco, and it is against the law to employ children under the age of 15. Nevertheless, thousands of families in urban areas have young girls (“petites bonnes”) who do their housework, some as young as five years old. The main reasons for child labor are family poverty, traditions and a lack of schooling (particularly for girls). The Moroccan government is aware of the problem, and is preparing to introduce a bill that will ban all employment of children in households. A national plan of action for the next ten years has also been adopted, which will create school programs and provide financial assistance to poor families. In addition, Princess Lalla Meryem, the oldest sister of King Mohammed VI, has taken on the problem of child labor in her country. A children’s parliament is addressing the issues of child abuse and exploitation.

Ban on discrimination in employment and occupation
While Article 8 of the Moroccan constitution guarantees equal political rights to both genders, in Morocco’s Islamic society women are disadvantaged relative to men. There are only a few female entrepreneurs, for example. However, Moroccan society is undergoing a process of modernization. Not only women’s legal situation, but also their actual lives have dramatically improved, thanks primarily to the 2004 reform of family law (Mudawana). Morocco is seeking to reduce or eliminate discrimination against women by introducing a national strategy for gender equality. Women are now better represented and more visible in the public arena: The cabinet now includes five women – three ministers and two ministers of state – and ten percent of seats in parliament are reserved for women.

Economic initiatives – CSR tools for private industry

GLOBAL COMPACT network
Morocco’s Global Compact network, which has been in place since 2006, currently has 24 members.
http://www.unglobalcompact.org/NetworksAroundTheWorld/
local_network_sheet/MA.html

On-site contact 
Mr. Saad Filali Meknassi
pactemondialmaroc (at) menara (dot) ma

Areas of activity

Poverty

Basic information

  • Life expectancy: Total population: 75.47 years; male: 72.42 years; female: 76.68 years (2009 est.)
  • Infant mortality: 29.75 deaths/1,000 live births; boys: 34.77 deaths/1,000 live births; girls: 24.49 deaths/1,000 live births (2009 est.)
  • Malnutrition: 6% (2006)
  • Access to clean water: 81%
  • Access to sanitary facilities: Rural population: 54%; urban: 85% (2006)
  • Human Poverty Index ranking: 97th (2007)
  • Gini Index: 40.9 (1992 – 2007)
  • Population below the poverty line: 15% (2007)

In its 2007 strategy paper on cooperation with Morocco, the European Union noted that increased economic growth alone was not sufficient for combating unemployment and poverty, which affects 15 percent of the population. Targeted efforts to promote employment are also in the interest of EU migration policy, which is seeking an end to the downward spiral of weak economic growth – unemployment – poverty – migration. German firms, too, might become involved in this area.

Participants

Initiative Nationale pour le Développement Humain – INDH
The national initiative for human development supports local development projects, assists communities, social workers and participatory organizations in developing their implementation skills, and maintains a network of experts.
http://www.indh.ma/fr/index.asp

Agence nationale pour la promotion de la petite et moyenne entreprise
The national agency for small and medium-sized enterprises supports companies and sponsoring organizations in the process of modernization.
http://www.anpme.ma

Yamana
The Fibre Citoyenne program helps decision makers in the textile industry to structure their activities in a socially and ecologically sustainable way. The program is implemented by the Yamana organization.
http://www.fibrecitoyenne.org/index.php?id=12&L=1http://www.fibrecitoyenne.org/index.php?id=12&L=1

Moroccan Association of Textile and Clothing Industries (AMITH)
AMITH serves as a contact for projects in the textile sector.
http://www.textile.ma

Engagement opportunities

  1. German companies might increase their investment activity, which will create jobs. In addition, an increase in manufacturers’ in-house production and greater use of local providers by German trading companies can help to reduce unemployment.
  2. Opening up new industries (such as ecotourism and solar energy) is another way of creating more jobs and thereby reducing poverty. KfW is already involved in the Plan d’Electrification Rurale Globale (PERG), which is working to link rural areas to the power network.

Company examples

Metro AG
A PPP project involving GTZ and Germany’s METRO Group has been under way since the end of 2007 for the purpose of training local providers as a way of raising food standards and promoting better hygiene. A long-term goal is to increase food exports to the EU. 
http://www.gtz.de/en/aktuell/21789.htm

Argand’Or GmbH
The Argand’Or company purchases raw oil from the argan tree from the members of the Union des Coopératives des Femmes de l’Arganeraie. Berber women who are skilled at hand-pressing argan oil have joined together in cooperatives under the umbrella of this organization. Some 23 cooperatives, which include about 1,000 women, organize the cultivation of the argan trees as well as harvesting, storage and production. Through their efforts, they support roughly 6,000 people.
http://www.argandor.de/soziale-verantwortung.html

COGNIS GmbH
Specialty chemicals supplier Cognis also purchases its argan oil from women’s cooperatives. This company has launched an extensive project that includes not only fair-trade guidelines, but also training for the cooperatives and a medical and cultural component.
http://www.cognis.com/company/Company/Sustainability/
Sustainability+put+into+practice/Argan+Case+Study/Argan+Case+Study.htm

Education

In his 2007 speech from the throne, King Mohammed VI singled out education in Morocco as a “point noir” – a weak point. Every Moroccan government has set aside generous funds for the country’s educational system. Despite these efforts, 48 percent of people over the age of 15 are illiterate. The percentage is even greater in rural areas and among women and girls.

Basic information

  • Public spending on education (share of GDP): 6% (2006)
  • Compulsory school attendance: 7–13 years
  • Rate of school enrollment: 92% (2008)
  • Literacy (definition: individuals ≥15 years of age who can read and write): 52% (2006)
  • HDI Education Index: 149th, 0.563 (1=max., 0=no education)

In 1999, the government set the goal of 100-percent school enrollment by 2002. Even today, however, that goal has not been achieved. Ninety-two percent of six-year-olds are registered for primary school (2008), which is an improvement, but the percentage is considerably lower for secondary schools, where only 37 percent of boys and 32 percent of girls are enrolled.

It is a major advantage that schools are free. Particularly in rural areas, however, children often have to go a long distance to the closest school, which has a negative effect on attendance. Moreover, schools and universities are widely regarded as providing inadequate preparation for entering the labor market. Primary school lessons are taught in Arabic, while French is the language used in secondary schools. The Berber language Amazigh has also been introduced in recent years as a way of reducing the language barriers faced by primary school students.

Participants

Morocco’s Ministry of Education
http://www.men.gov.uk/

Syndicat National de l'enseignement Supérieur (SNESUP)
The union of higher education employees represents the interests of its members in the reform and development of the higher education system.
E-Mail: snesup.maroc (at) gmail (dot) com
Tel/Fax: 00 212 (0) 537 77 60 74
http://www.snesup.ma/contact.html

Although state universities are free, they are overcrowded and poorly equipped. In addition, Morocco’s labor market provides too few jobs for academics, many of whom decide to move abroad. To solve this problem, a university reform initiative has made changes in course content, shortened the length of degree programs and brought Moroccan degrees up to international standards.

Company examples

GTZ
GTZ is helping the Moroccan government to introduce practical basic training for young people (most of them women) so that they are qualified for jobs in the textile and apparel industry and in tourism. The aim is to help Morocco improve its educational standards in preparation for the free-trade zone with the EU that will go into effect in 2012. Here the focus is on introducing a dual training system.
http://www.gtz.de/de/weltweit/maghreb-naher-osten/marokko/6409.htm

Robinson Club
The Agadir Robinson Club is participating in a GTZ-sponsored project to reform vocational training (FPMT), and also providing further training for its own junior employees. Qualified employees are essential for high-quality services, and therefore crucial to a company's business success.
http://marokko.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=147:robinson-club-in-agadir&catid=90:ihk-casablanca-informiert&Itemid=203

A lack of skilled workers is a significant obstacle to the development of the Moroccan economy. Gearing vocational training more closely to the demands of the labor market and corporate expectations is a crucial challenge for Morocco. Germany’s experience with its dual, cooperative system of vocational training is highly regarded. Such foreign companies as Renault and Robinson Club Agadir have begun to open their own schools for training their employees.

Health

According to a study by Germany Trade and Invest (gtai), Morocco’s healthcare system is not yet comparable to international standards. There is an average of one physician for every 1,800 people, and in rural areas the ratio can be as high as one to 3,330. While Morocco has enough physicians, many of them are unemployed because of a lack of funding for the healthcare system.

Basic information

  • Public spending on health (share of GDP): 1.7% (2004)
  • Medical care: 1 physician per 1,800 people
  • Life expectancy: Total population: 75.47 years; male: 72.42 years; female: 76.68 years (2009 est.)
  • Infant mortality: 29.75 deaths/1,000 births; boys: 34.77 deaths/1,000 births; girls: 24.49 deaths/1,000 births (2009 est.)
  • Maternal mortality: 230 deaths per 100,000 live births
  • Child malnutrition: 10% (2000 – 2006)
  • HIV/AIDS prevalence rate (>15 years of age): 0.1% (2007)
  • HIV/AIDS sufferers: 21,000 (2007)
  • HIV/AIDS deaths: fewer than 1,000 (2007 est.)

Access to hospitals is inadequate as well: There are only four university hospitals, in Casa, Rabat, Marrakech and Fès. Provincial hospitals are available to roughly four percent of the population. Ninety-five percent of the people, particularly in rural areas, depend on outpatient clinics, staffed only by nurses, for their basic healthcare needs.

Morocco has a high rate of maternal mortality: There are 230 maternal deaths – roughly 270 in rural areas – for every 100,000 births. By comparison, the relevant figure for the neighboring country of Algeria is 140. Infant mortality is high as well: In Morocco, an average of 30 babies die for every 1,000 births. The main reason is inadequate care during childbirth.

Participants

Association Marocaine de L’ Industrie Pharmaceutique
The Moroccan pharmaceutical association is developing industry standards and guidelines (which also address ecological and social issues) and compiling studies and informational materials for the pharmaceutical sector.
http://www.amip.ma/

Moroccan Ministry of Health
http://www.sante.gov.ma

Since the end of 2005, a statutory insurance mandate has been gradually introduced with the goal of making healthcare affordable for all and financing efforts to modernize the system. The government is also planning to build 28 new hospitals and establish emergency care centers. It is setting aside about €450 million for that purpose.

Source: Deutsch-marokkanische Gesellschaft, German Embassy, Rabat

Participation in society

Basic information

  • Women as a percentage of the workforce: 38.2%
  • Ethnic groups: Arab-Berber (99.1%), Jews (0.2%), other (0.7%)

Women and men have equal rights under Moroccan law. Education for girls has improved over the last few decades, and women are now involved in every sphere of the economy. However, German companies need to be aware that Moroccan society is still marked by a traditional division of roles. Traditionally, women are subordinate to their husbands and responsible for their households and families.

Participants

Association de Femmes Chefs D’ Entreprises Du Maroc
The association of women entrepreneurs in Morocco supports its members and represents their interests in the public arena.
Association of women entrepreneurs
http://www.afem.ma

Azalay e.V.
This organization helps preserve the nomadic way of life. Azalay e.V. supports nomadic populations in the Moroccan Sahara whose existence is threatened.
http://www.azalay.de

Secrétariat d'Etat auprès du Ministre du Développement Social, de la Famille et de la Solidarité
State Secretary for Families, Childhood and the Disabled
http://www.sefsas.gov.ma

Tränenmond e.V.
Tränenmond e.V. supports the Oum el Banine women’s shelter in Agadir, the mud-hut village of Igraar at the edge of the Sahara, and the center for the protection of children in Agadir.
http://www.traenenmond.de

German companies can contribute to equal participation by women in the workplace by providing equal pay for equal work, encouraging women to take initiative and assigning leadership positions to women. By doing so, international companies help to dismantle outdated concepts of gender roles and demonstrate how gender equality can be achieved.

Environment

Morocco faces a variety of challenges related to the environment: combating desertification, protecting endangered environments such as oases, conserving water resources, and waste management. There is little awareness of these issues in Moroccan society, and in most cases the political sphere is only beginning to address them.

Basic information

  • CO2 emissions: 0.2% of total global emissions (2006)
  • CO2 emissions per capita: 1.47 metric tons (2006)
  • Energy consumption: 20.78 billion kWh (2007 est.)
  • Energy consumption per capita: approximately 715 kWh (2009)
  • Water consumption (households/industry/agriculture): Total: 12.6 km3/year (10%/3%/87%)
  • Water consumption per capita: 400 m3/year (2000)

Accordingly, international companies in Morocco play an important role in encouraging environmental engagement. So far the focus has been on the proper disposal of environmentally damaging sewage and waste materials and on recycling packaging materials and outdated equipment, for example in the electronics industry. However, German companies might also act as a role model by taking advantage of their expertise in the sustainable use of natural resources like water, air and soil. International companies, which are already operating in a responsible way and adhering to international standards, are calling for a more robust statutory framework and enhanced monitoring of compliance.

Company examples

Bayer CropScience
Together with the GTZ environmental program and the Moroccan Ministry of the Environment, Bayer CropScience Maroc is planning a project to promote the proper disposal of pesticide packaging.
http://www.bayercropscience.com/bcsweb/cropprotection.nsf/id/
20080207_EN

Hewlett Packard
Hewlett Packard is funding a research project on recycling electronic scrap materials, which will be implemented in Morocco and other countries.
http://www.empa.ch/plugin/template/empa/3/63914/---/l=1

Holcim and GTZ
Together with GTZ, the cement manufacturer Holcim Maroc has developed standards for safely burning waste materials, including hazardous waste, in cement ovens.
http://www.gtz.de/de/aktuell/16454.htm

In cooperation with international companies and the Moroccan Ministry of Energy, GTZ is engaged in several projects related to environmental protection, renewable sources of energy and energy efficiency. The German Chamber of Commerce Abroad (AHK) is active in the Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency Export Initiative.

Participants

Observatoire National pour l’Environnement – ONE
The national environmental watch collects and disseminates information on the state of the environment in Morocco. 
http://www.minenv.gov.ma/onem/index.asp

Réseau pour la conformité et la mise en vigueur de la législation environnementale – NECEMA
A network for introducing and upholding environmental protection legislation.
http://www.inece.org/mena/necema/

Biota Africa
Biota Africa is a research network on the topic of biodiversity on the African continent.
http://www.biota-africa.org/aboutus_struc_ba.php?Page_ID=L900

Opening up new industries such as ecotourism and solar energy is another way of promoting environmental protection. KfW Bank is already involved in the Plan d’Electrification Rurale Globale (PERG), which is working to link rural areas to the power network.